Close Menu
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Celtic Shorts
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Subscribe
    • Latest News
    • Transfer News
    • Supporters
    • Videos
    • Celtic Stories
    • On This Day
    • Celtic History
    • Celtic FC Women
    • Our Writers
    • About
    Celtic Shorts
    Home»Latest News»Scottish Cup Final Definitive Ratings – ‘Some people just get hysterical about Celtic for no reason’
    Latest News

    Scottish Cup Final Definitive Ratings – ‘Some people just get hysterical about Celtic for no reason’

    Sandman's Scottish Cup Final Definitive Ratings on Celtic Shorts...
    David FauldsBy David FauldsMay 24, 20262 Comments11 Mins Read
    Share Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Follow Us
    Google News Flipboard Threads
    Martin O'Neill with the Scottish Cup
    23.05.2026 Celtic v Dunfermline Athletic, Scottish Cup Final - Martin O'Neill with the Scottish Cup. Photo Kenny Ramsay
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

    SANDMAN’S DEFINITIVE RATINGS: CELTIC v THE SKIDS…

    “Into the valley, betrothed and divine
    Realisation’s no virtue, but who can define
    Why soldiers go marching, those masses in line?
    This disease is catching from victory to stone

    Ahoy! Ahoy! Land, sea and sky
    Ahoy! Ahoy! Boy, man and soldier
    Ahoy! Ahoy! Deceived and then punctured
    Ahoy! Ahoy! Long may they die”

    – ‘Into The Valley’ Lyrics by Stuart Adamson/Luke McCowan

    VINDALOO – 6/10 – After you. No, after you… No… And the curse of good manners almost costs us a crazy gifted opener as Vinny and AJ discuss the merits of courtesy. Just one of those things, hesitation and second-guessing, when it really just requires a boot out of the park and acceptance of consequences avoided. Did act as a wake-up call, though, and for the rest of the game he was in-tune with his defence when required.

    Kieran Tierney with the Scottish Cup
    23.05.2026 Celtic v Dunfermline Athletic, Scottish Cup Final – Kieran Tierney with the Scottish Cup. Photo Kenny Ramsay

    KATIE – 6/10 – It’s 50-odd games for the bhoy whose legs were ‘gone’. They certainly carried him as far as they could today. But the sharpness was dulled and though he made some fine supporting and overlapping bursts, the KT delivery mechanism was stuck on ‘phish’. Rest this man, or we won’t win the World Cup…

    Alistair Johnston
    23rd May 2026; Hampden Park, Scottish Cup Final Football, Celtic versus Dunfermline; Alistair Johnston of Celtic raises a fist to the fans as he walks past the trophy. Photo Vagelis Georgariou

    WAYNE GRETZKY – 6/10 – A more subdued Moose than usual. Low energy, it seemed; possibly a result of the high-intensity of his run-in comeback. Certainly befuddled in that early mix-up, but made amends with an astute long ball to pick out Daizen for the opener.

    Auston Trusty with the Scottish Cup.
    23.05.2026 Celtic v Dunfermline Athletic, Scottish Cup Final. Auston Trusty with the Scottish Cup. Photo Kenny Ramsay

    CRUSTY THE CLOWN – 6.5/10 – Booked for being hauled to the ground is a new one. So congrats on the MIB innovation to give big Austin plenty to think about as the Pars introduced two Eastern-European Balkan War mercenaries down the middle after half-time. So in his last game of a season he started isolated somewhere near Antarctica, he went into mortal combat under a scorching sun. And, thankfully, he held his own, rebuffing a number of assaults, half of them intimate, as Dunfermline’s big maddies attempted to leave their mark on everything that moved in green and white.

    Liam Scales with the Scottish Cup
    Scottish Cup Final – Liam Scales with the Scottish Cup. Photo Kenny Ramsay

    OF JUSTICE – 7.5/10 – It almost writes itself, a Liam assessment. Vast percentage of the time this season you could start with the low expectations of derisive ingrates and explain how he exceeds them, often proving himself crucial to a major result. So.. Here we go again: Anticipation and reaction of a praying mantis to prevent the shock lead a country beyond our hooped kingdom was fervently wishing for; Bailing out his stuttering cohorts while doing so. Floating passes in-behind like prime Glen Hoddle. Clearing up scraps from his partner’s buffering battles with rowdy strikers and cutting out direct through balls like prime… Baresi. A ginger one… Yet again, we note. And yet again, Scales The Understated is the foundation of a fine Celtic victory.

    Callum McGregor lifts the Scottish Cup
    23.05.2026 Celtic v Dunfermline Athletic, Scottish Cup Final . Callum McGregor lifts the Scottish Cup. Photo Kenny Ramsay

    CALMAC – 7/10 – Butch Cassidy And The Sundance Kid. Now showing on the Hampden pitch. Calmac and his young sidekick smoked the upstart Fifers Gang, led by former rebel alliance leader Lenny Lennon…With the Belgian bhoy in sparkling form, the skipper got the freedom of the park to dictate the show. And we got a rich, enthralling display through a first 45 that won the day. Game-management took precedence as the league surge finally took its toll on the Celtic energy levels and emotions later in the match. But Calmac kept his charges on-point to see it out and get his hands back on the knockout trophy most associated with the Hoops.

    Arne Engels
    23rd May 2026; Hampden Park, Scottish Cup Final. Celtic versus Dunfermline; Celtic coach Mark Fotheringham and Arne Engels of Celtic. Photo Vagelis Georgariou

    THE TERMINATOR – 8/10 MOTM – Fighting fit, mean and pivotal. Young Arne on a mission is the £25 million player we require, and the one who showed up today. The much-vaunted dynamic duo combo with Calmac worked to provide us perfect harmonic control for a dominating opening half. He outshone the Hampden sun, skelping in a beauty of second goal to give us breathing space. But it was his overall intensity that kept up a killer tempo and staged a classy cup-winning midfield performance.

    Benjamin Nygren with the Scottish Cup
    23.05.2026 Celtic v Dunfermline Athletic, Scottish Cup Final. Benjamin Nygren with the Scottish Cup. Photo Kenny Ramsay

    NEGAN – 6/10 – Having squeezed Reo completely out of the picture, the Swedish conundrum has been out to prove his worth; which should consist of greater presence and influence in game. Today he was borderline AWOL, but come the second half had refined his movement between their lines and popped up in many a dangerous position with time and space to operate. and it was from this that he finally got his – and our reward – laying on the third goal.

    James Forrest celebrates with goalscorer Daizen Maeda
    23rd May 2026; Hampden Park; Scottish Cup Final Football, Celtic versus Dunfermline; Daizen Maeda of Celtic celebrates with James Forrest of Celtic after he shoots and scores in the 19th minute to make it 1-0 to Celtic. Photo Vagelis Georgariou

    JAMESY – 6.5/10 – What’s that? Yes, MON does read these and did in fact apply the “need to score, inject some Jamesy” maxim from the first whistle. And lo and behold, we’re two up at the break…And before his libido faded at his millionth medal win, Jamesy had looked the man most likely – firing in our only decent crosses, stinging the keeper’s gloves with our first SOT. A cunning ploy from the boss to start him, shooting towards the away end; plenty new burds there to impress that Jamesy hadn’t ‘seen’ before. And will probably be seeing-to as you read this…

    Daizen Maeda with the Scottish Cup.
    23.05.2026 Celtic v Dunfermline Athletic, Scottish Cup Final. Daizen Maeda with the Scottish Cup. Photo Kenny Ramsay

    LORD KATSUMOTO – 7.5/10 – The Samurai King signs off with his 17th of the season and 79th of a Celtic career which is now cemented in legendary foreigner status, up there beside Nakamura. His unique pressing style drew blood one last time, spooking their centre-half into misjudging the flight of a long ball, and Daizen pounced. For he never sleeps, you know. He waits. The finish was sublime, from “oNe Of thE WorSteSt PlAyUrs iN a CeLtiC sHiRt” some have ever seen…So a final honour for the honourable Maeda-San, and his
    many-folded blade which has ripped a swathe through Scottish football. In the words of Jacqueline McCafferty, “Ah flamin’ love you, man!”

    Yang lifts the Scottish Cup
    23.05.2026 Celtic v Dunfermline Athletic, Scottish Cup Final. Yang lifts the Scottish Cup. . Photo Kenny Ramsay

    YING – 6/10 – Another match, another busy bee, and another outing more huff than *phooov!* (that’s alluding to a dazzling magical spell, not to Raskin of the Zombies..). If he could just calm down a bit and blend in more of the skilful instinct we saw in clipped passes or a sweet outside of the boot delivery, we’d have a proper player.

    SUBS –

    Kelechi Iheanacho of Celtic
    23rd May 2026; Hampden Park, Scottish Cup Final, Celtic versus Dunfermline; Kelechi Iheanacho of Celtic celebrates after he rounds Aston Oxborough of Dunfermline Athletic and shoots and scores to make it 3-0 in the 73rd minute. Photo Vagelis Georgariou

    ITCHYCOO PARK – 7/10 – Our impact sub of the season. He’s a big unit, Kelechi, and he’s only half-fit, but the natural ability’s there in those deft feet; As Fred Astaire* will attest to after watching him bamboozle a couple of defenders before shimmying round the keeper to seal the win.

    *Fred Astaire is dead. Like Rangers.

    Kelechi Iheanacho, Benjamin Nygren and Seb Tounekti.
    23.05.2026 Celtic v Dunfermline Athletic, Scottish Cup Final -Kelechi Iheanacho, Benjamin Nygren and Seb Tounekti. Photo Kenny Ramsay

    TUTANKHAMUN – N/A – Loves a trophy win, this kid. Enjoys himself regardless of weight of contribution; which has been a bit lacking, much in the vein of today’s lightweight cameo.

    Alex Oxlade Chamberlain
    23rd May 2026; Hampden Park, Scottish Cup Final, Celtic versus Dunfermline; Alex Oxlade Chamberlain of Celtic with the trophy. Photo Vagelis Georgariou

    NEVILLE – N/A – The Ox flips a few passes about to give us a last glimpse of his class. Thank you, Sir.

    Marcelo Saracchi, Paulo Bernardo and Michel-Ange Balikwisha celebrate
    16.05.2026 Celtic v Hearts, Scottish Premiership. Marcelo Saracchi, Paulo Bernardo and Michel-Ange Balikwisha celebrate. Photo Kenny Ramsay IMAGO / News Licensing

    SCRATCHY – N/A – If we can’t retain this energetic little madman from Uruguay, it would have been nice to see him depart with a cup final goal. Unfortunately fluffed his big moment right at the death when he half-volleyed a chance into the Celtic end like it was the decapitated head of a rival cartel sicario.

    Callum McGregor lifts the cup with Martin O'Neill.
    23.05.2026 Celtic v Dunfermline Athletic, Scottish Cup Final.Callum McGregor lifts the cup with Martin O’Neill. Photo Kenny Ramsay

    FATHER MARTIN AND SAMWISE GANGEE 8.5/10 – A double for the double act, a glorious finale for the genial legend. It all seemed so abrupt as the final whistle blew – the ridiculous Hollywood ending you’d dared to dream of two months ago as the chips went down and the probabilities tallied up to not much…So we and he, and they, can all breathe easy now. No shocks, no drama, just focussed discipline and jobs well done one last time to finish with an extra flourish after last week’s showstopper. MON barely tweaked it bar the genius Jamesy inclusion, and trusted the Bhoys had sobered up enough to take care of this last piece of business to make the boss’s comeback special to rival that of Elvis.

    So now we talk of statue spots on The Celtic Way. And of long walks into the sunset, legend assured. But the crew? The rest of the band? Shaun O’Maloney, Fozzy, Gav and.. .the drummer? A difficult one…It’s like the very end of Cheers, you see, when Sam Malone tells the gang he’s selling the bar and quitting Boston.

    “What will become of us?” asks Norm, Cliff and Frasier, forlornly. And what did? Well, there was a twist: Sammy changed his mind and stayed. Forever, so far as we knew; being left with only the ultimate final credits and teary pathos as a decade of epic comic brilliance came to a close. Will there be such a twist at Celtic, now? Hmm…

    23rd May 2026; Hampden Park, Scottish Cup Final Football, Celtic versus Dunfermline; Martin ONeill on a fans t-shirt. Photo Vagelis Georgariou

    MIBBERY – 2/10 – Any last requests? VAR controversy? Manufactured outrage over volleyball moves on a football pitch? Nope. Just the Celts ruining the sunny day in the ludges beer gardens. AGAIN.

    OVERALL – 8/10 – The crowning glory. The hated double, done and dusted. ‘What if?’ of weeks ago became
    ‘WTF? They did it!’ in some decent style. Certainly the first-half from around the quarter hour to the break was satisfying champions fodder – brisk tempo, confident interchanges, smooth rotation and inventive play, all based off zippy possession and great intense application. Legs got a bit wobbly – unsurprisingly – deep into the game but the reinforcements introduced did their parts – again, in spectacular fashion. So it all went as planned and we took both trophies to make up for the St.Mirren aberration.

    Celtic Park after the Scottish Cup Final
    23rd May 2026; Celtic Park after the Scottish Cup Final, Celtic versus Dunfermline; Aerial drone shot of the team and trophies at Celtic Park. 23rd May 2026. Photo Vagelis Georgariou

    As written. Never in doubt. So, what was all the flaming fuss about? Honestly, some people just get hysterical about Celtic for no reason… More of this nonsense coming up in a graphically explicit Season Review – soon; just to antagonise more people before Tony Ralston lifts the World Cup.

    See you around…

    Go Away Now

    Sandman

    HAVE YOUR SAY – Join the Celtic conversation in our comments section below…

    The Perfect Father's Day Gift- both books for just £20 plus P&P
    The Perfect Father’s Day Gift- both books for just £20 plus P&P. Order now at Celticstarbooks.com

    Quick Tip – Add Celticshorts.com as your ‘Preferred Source’ on Google News for quick access to the Celtic content you value the most. It takes just a few seconds and you’ll notice the difference straight away! – Click HERE….Hail Hail!

    Click to join Celtic Pools
    Click to join Celtic Pools
    Celtic 3 Dunfermline 1 Celtic Player ratings Celticshorts.com Latest Celtic news Sandman Sandman's Definitive Ratings Scottish Cup Final 2026
    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    David Faulds

    Founder and editor on Celtic Shorts and publisher on dozens of top quality Celtic books including those on celticstarbooks.com. Publisher on The Celtic Star ahead of its sale. Earliest Celtic memories are a win over East Fife at Celtic Park and the 4-1 League Cup loss to Partick Thistle as a 6 year old. Best game? Easy 4-2, 1979 when Ten Men Won the League. Email me if you'd like to get involved. editor@celticshorts.com

    Related Posts

    Celtic and World Cup stadia

    June 16, 2026

    Celtic return home to a wedding and three funerals

    June 16, 2026

    Greg Taylor on key moments at key part of the season that won Celtic the league

    June 16, 2026

    2 Comments

    1. Wilkinssscreamer on May 24, 2026 1:08 pm

      Buckie again?

    2. Lubo's Boots on May 24, 2026 9:26 pm

      That Fred Astaire comment 🤣

    As featured on NewsNow: Celtic Football news
    Celtic News 24/7  
    Celtic FC News
    Celtic Shorts Social Channels
    Follow @celtic_shorts
    Celtic Star Magazine
    Celtic Shorts Bookstore
    Celtic Pools
    © 2026 ThemeSphere. Designed by ThemeSphere.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.