Close Menu
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Celtic Shorts
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Subscribe
    • Latest News
    • Transfer News
    • Supporters
    • Videos
    • Celtic Stories
    • On This Day
    • Celtic History
    • Celtic FC Women
    • Our Writers
    • About
    Celtic Shorts
    Home»Latest News»Celtic’s Failed Nancy Experiment – “It obviously wasn’t the right time,” admits Celtic star
    Latest News

    Celtic’s Failed Nancy Experiment – “It obviously wasn’t the right time,” admits Celtic star

    "Look, I think he's a great manager. His football does work," Alistair Johnston
    Paul GillespieBy Paul GillespieMay 27, 2026No Comments5 Mins Read
    Share Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Follow Us
    Google News Flipboard Threads
    Celtic Manager Wilfried Nancy
    Celtic Manager Wilfried Nancy arriving at the ground ahead of the Scottish Premiership match between Livingston and Celtic at Set Fare Arena on December 27, 2025. (Photo by WM Sport Media/Getty Images)
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

    Alistair Johnston knew Wilfried Nancy more than most when the Frenchman arrived on these shores from North American football and reckons that his former coach’s ill-fated spell does not mean that he is by any stretch of the imagination a poor manager…

    Michael Nicholson and the Celtic Board went all in on their man

    Nancy answered the call when Celtic were searching for a Brendan Rodgers replacement, following a near-perfect Martin O’Neill interim spell in late autumn. Michael Nicholson and the Celtic Board went all in on their man and brought the relatively unknown coach to these shores after coughing up significant compensation to his club Columbus Crew.

    Johnston played under Nancy at CF Montreal a few seasons ago and is of the mind that it was a case of the wrong time for Wilfried at Celtic Park.

    “Look, I think he’s a great manager. His football does work”

    The Canadian international witnessed his talents first-hand and is certain things would have been different had he joined in the close season. Speaking on the whole Nancy debacle, AJ said: “Look, I think he’s a great manager. His football does work.

    “Whatever the case was, it obviously wasn’t the right time. But that’s not to say he can’t go to another European club or wherever and make it work,” as reported by Daily Record.

    Johnston revealed that perhaps a full pre-season to get his ideas across would be more appropriate, and may have allowed the coach to get his ideas on the game across more clearly.

    “Would a pre-season probably have helped? I do think so”

    “Would a pre-season probably have helped? I do think so,” he said. “Whenever you’re trying to do a completely different style of football and introduce some really new ideas, it definitely helps to have friendly matches to really work on things.”

    The Celtic full-back admitted though that that’s the business they’re in and that big clubs demand success instantly.

    He continued: “But that’s also the challenge of working at a club like this – you don’t necessarily get time. Especially when you come in mid-season, you need to hit the ground running, and I think that’s something he was acutely aware of. Unfortunately, it didn’t work out, but I’ve got no doubt in mind that he’s going to go somewhere else and be a huge success.”

    Alistair Johnston
    23rd May 2026; Hampden Park, Scottish Cup Final Football, Celtic versus Dunfermline; Alistair Johnston of Celtic raises a fist to the fans as he walks past the trophy. Photo Vagelis Georgariou

    “Yeah, it was tough, just because I couldn’t be out on the grass”

    To make matters worse, Johnston was out with a recurring hamstring injury, which meant he had to look on in agony as his old boss was battered from pillar to post during his stint in the Parkhead dugout.

    “Yeah, it was tough, just because I couldn’t be out on the grass. I knew what he wanted to implement and how different it would be compared to what we’re used to here. It was just tough being injured and not being able to get out on the grass and help things, and help guys understand exactly what he was trying to look for.”

    Celtic manager Wilfried Nancy and Shin Yamada
    Celtic manager Wilfried Nancy and Shin Yamada are seen during the Scottish Premiership match between Celtic and Aberdeen at Celtic Park on December 21, 2025. (Photo by Ian MacNicol/Getty Images)

    Lost in translation

    He added: “Again, French is his first language – there are a couple of things that can get lost in translation a little bit. I was just trying my best, especially off the pitch, just to help guys out. But it’s never the same when you’re off the pitch, trying to talk guys through it versus being out there and helping them through. It was a really sticky period. We dropped quite a few points there. It was quite a low in my time at the club. We never had results like that in such a prolonged period. It was difficult.”

    Aye, it sure was Alistair.

    Paul Gillespie

    HAVE YOUR SAY – Join the Celtic conversation in our comments section below…

    The Perfect Father's Day Gift- both books for just £20 plus P&P
    The Perfect Father’s Day Gift- both books for just £20 plus P&P. Order now at Celticstarbooks.com

    Quick Tip – Add Celticshorts.com as your ‘Preferred Source’ on Google News for quick access to the Celtic content you value the most. It takes just a few seconds and you’ll notice the difference straight away! – Click HERE….Hail Hail!

    Click to join Celtic Pools
    Click to join Celtic Pools
    Alistair Johnston Celtic FC News Celticshorts.com Latest Celtic news Paul Gillepsie Wilfried Nancy
    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Paul Gillespie

    Related Posts

    Andy Burnham’s Celtic connection as PM reveals second club behind Everton

    July 21, 2026

    Derek Rae tells Celtic fans what to expect from Mika Baur

    July 21, 2026

    Fabrizio Romano confirms Celtic have agreed personal terms with midfield target

    July 21, 2026

    Comments are closed.

    As featured on NewsNow: Celtic Football news
    Celtic News 24/7  
    Celtic FC News
    Celtic Shorts Social Channels
    Follow @celtic_shorts
    Celtic Star Magazine
    Celtic Shorts Bookstore
    Celtic Pools
    © 2026 ThemeSphere. Designed by ThemeSphere.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.